Choosing the right carry-on luggage can make or break your travel experience. The perfect bag not only meets airline size restrictions but also organizes your belongings efficiently, withstands the rigors of travel, and complements your personal style. Whether you’re a frequent business traveler or an occasional vacationer, investing in quality carry-on luggage saves you from checked bag fees, eliminates waiting at baggage claim, and provides peace of mind knowing your essentials are always with you. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare the top carry-on options on the market to help you find your ideal travel companion.
Carry-On Luggage Comparison Table
| Brand/Model | Dimensions | Weight | Material | Special Features | Price Range |
| Travelpro Platinum Elite 21″ | 23.5″ x 14.5″ x 9″ | 7.8 lbs | Ballistic nylon | USB port, expandable, MagnaTrac wheels | $365 |
| Away The Carry-On | 21.7″ x 14.4″ x 9″ | 7.5 lbs | Polycarbonate shell | Ejectable battery, TSA-approved lock | $275-$295 |
| Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential | 22″ x 14″ x 9″ | 10 lbs | Ballistic nylon | CX expansion system, garment folder | $679-$699 |
| Travelpro Maxlite 5 21″ | 23″ x 14.5″ x 9″ | 5.4 lbs | Polyester | Lightweight design, expandable | $144 |
| Carl Friedrik The Carry-On | 21.6″ x 14.5″ x 9″ | 8.6 lbs | Polycarbonate, aluminum frame | Leather accents, TSA-approved locks | $595 |
| Yeti Crossroads 22″ | 22″ x 14″ x 9″ | 8 lbs | 700-denier nylon, polycarbonate back | Rugged design, heavy-duty wheels | $350 |
| Patagonia Black Hole MLC 45L | 22″ x 14.5″ x 7.6″ | 3.6 lbs | Recycled polyester ripstop | Backpack straps, multiple carry options | $239 |
Types of Carry-On Luggage
Before diving into specific recommendations, it’s helpful to understand the main types of carry-on luggage available today:
Hardside Spinners
Featuring rigid polycarbonate or ABS plastic shells, these suitcases offer excellent protection for fragile items. Their four multidirectional wheels allow 360° movement, making them easy to maneuver through crowded airports. Hardside luggage typically opens like a book with two equal compartments.
Softside Rollers
Made from durable fabrics like ballistic nylon or polyester, these bags offer more flexibility for squeezing into tight overhead bins. They typically feature external pockets for easy access to travel documents and often have expansion capabilities. Available in both two-wheel and four-wheel designs.
Travel Backpacks
Perfect for adventure travelers, these carry-ons distribute weight across your shoulders and back. Modern travel backpacks open like suitcases for easy packing and often include compression straps, multiple compartments, and sometimes even wheels for versatility.
Best Soft-Sided Carry-On: Travelpro Platinum Elite 21″ Spinner
The Travelpro Platinum Elite has consistently ranked as one of the best carry-on luggage options for nearly a decade, and for good reason. This premium soft-sided spinner offers an exceptional balance of durability, functionality, and sophisticated design that appeals to both business and leisure travelers.
Pros
- Exceptional lifetime warranty that covers airline damage
- Premium MagnaTrac self-aligning wheels for smooth maneuverability
- Expandable design with 2″ of additional packing space
- Includes removable garment bag for wrinkle-free clothing
- External USB port for charging devices (battery not included)
- Durable ballistic nylon exterior resists stains and abrasions
Cons
- Slightly heavier than some competitors at 7.8 pounds
- Premium price point (though justified by quality)
- Skid plate could be more protective for stair dragging
- USB pass-through cable adds potential failure point
The Platinum Elite excels at organization with its thoughtfully designed interior featuring tie-down straps and compression panels that keep clothes neat without creasing. The external pockets provide easy access to travel essentials, while the expansion zipper offers flexibility when you need extra space.
What truly sets this bag apart is Travelpro’s exceptional warranty service. When registered within 120 days of purchase, the Platinum Elite is covered by a lifetime warranty that includes airline damage and shipping to repair facilities—a level of protection typically only found in much more expensive luggage.
Ready for Your Next Adventure?
The Travelpro Platinum Elite combines premium features with exceptional durability for years of reliable travel.
Best Hard-Sided Carry-On: Away The Carry-On
Away has revolutionized the luggage industry with its direct-to-consumer model and sleek, minimalist design. The Carry-On has become an icon for modern travelers who want style and functionality without an exorbitant price tag.
Pros
- Sleek, modern design available in numerous color options
- Durable polycarbonate shell that flexes under pressure
- Smooth-rolling YKK zippers and premium Hinomoto wheels
- TSA-approved combination lock for security
- Interior compression system maximizes packing space
- Limited lifetime warranty covers shell, wheels, handles, and zippers
Cons
- Clamshell design can be awkward to pack in tight spaces
- Shows scratches more readily than soft-sided luggage
- No external pockets for quick access items
- No garment folder for business attire
Away’s Carry-On strikes an excellent balance between style and substance. The polycarbonate shell provides good protection while remaining lightweight at just 7.5 pounds. The interior features a compression system on one side and a mesh zippered compartment on the other, making organization straightforward.
For travelers who need a bit more space, Away also offers “The Bigger Carry-On” which pushes airline size limits slightly but still fits in most overhead bins. Both models come with Away’s limited lifetime warranty that covers any functional aspect of the bag.
Travel in Style
Away’s The Carry-On combines modern aesthetics with practical features for the contemporary traveler.
Best Budget Carry-On: Travelpro Maxlite 5 21″ Spinner
If you’re looking for quality luggage that won’t break the bank, the Travelpro Maxlite 5 offers exceptional value. This ultralight spinner weighs just 5.4 pounds—making it one of the lightest carry-ons on the market—without sacrificing durability or functionality.
Pros
- Incredibly lightweight at just 5.4 pounds
- Excellent price point around $144
- Expandable design for additional capacity
- Water and stain-resistant coating
- Backed by Travelpro’s trusted reputation
- Simple, functional interior organization
Cons
- Limited warranty compared to Platinum Elite line
- Fewer premium features than higher-end models
- Polyester exterior less durable than ballistic nylon
- Basic interior organization system
The Maxlite 5 achieves its remarkable lightness through clever engineering, including a honeycomb frame system and high-tensile fabric. Despite its budget-friendly price, it includes many features found in more expensive luggage: four spinner wheels, a telescoping handle with two height settings, and an expandable design.
While the warranty isn’t as comprehensive as Travelpro’s premium lines (covering manufacturing defects but not airline damage beyond the first year), the Maxlite 5 represents exceptional value for occasional travelers or those who prioritize lightweight design above all else.
Travel Light, Save Right
The Travelpro Maxlite 5 delivers remarkable quality at an affordable price point.
Best Luxury Carry-On: Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential
For frequent travelers who demand the absolute best, the Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential represents the pinnacle of luggage engineering. This premium carry-on combines innovative design with unparalleled durability and the industry’s most comprehensive warranty.
Pros
- Revolutionary CX expansion-compression system increases capacity by 25%
- Unconditional lifetime warranty covers all damage, even airline abuse
- Outside-mounted handle tubes maximize interior packing space
- Built-in garment folder prevents wrinkles in business attire
- Premium components including self-healing YKK zippers
- Exceptional build quality designed for decades of use
Cons
- Premium price point ($679-$699)
- Heavier than competitors at 10 pounds
- Understated design may be too conservative for some
- Exposed rails could use more protection
The standout feature of the Baseline Essential is its ingenious CX expansion-compression system. You can expand the bag by 2.5 inches for packing, then compress it back to standard carry-on dimensions—providing significantly more capacity than competitors while still fitting in overhead bins.
Briggs & Riley’s “Simple As That” warranty is truly unmatched: it covers any damage for the life of the bag, no questions asked. While the initial investment is substantial, the exceptional quality and warranty make this a true buy-it-for-life purchase that may actually save money in the long run.
Invest in Excellence
The Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential offers uncompromising quality and the industry’s best warranty.
Best for Adventure Travel: Patagonia Black Hole MLC 45L
For adventure travelers who need versatility and durability, the Patagonia Black Hole MLC (Maximum Legal Carry-on) 45L is the perfect companion. This hybrid backpack/duffel offers multiple carrying options and rugged construction that can handle everything from cobblestone streets to jungle trails.
Pros
- Versatile carrying options (backpack, shoulder bag, duffel)
- Extremely lightweight at just 3.6 pounds
- Made from 100% recycled materials
- Weather-resistant finish protects contents
- Backed by Patagonia’s Ironclad Guarantee
- Clamshell opening for easy packing and access
Cons
- No wheels for easy airport navigation
- Less structured than traditional suitcases
- Limited organization compared to dedicated business luggage
- Can be bulky when fully packed
The Black Hole MLC opens like a suitcase for easy packing but can be carried like a backpack when navigating rough terrain. Its recycled polyester ripstop fabric with TPU laminate offers excellent durability and weather resistance while maintaining Patagonia’s commitment to environmental responsibility.
Inside, you’ll find multiple organization pockets including a padded laptop sleeve and mesh dividers. The bag compresses well when not fully packed, making it adaptable to different trip lengths. For adventure travelers who value versatility and sustainability, this carry-on is hard to beat.
Adventure Awaits
The Patagonia Black Hole MLC offers versatile carrying options and eco-friendly construction for adventure travelers.
Carry-On Luggage Buying Guide
Size Restrictions
The most critical factor when choosing carry-on luggage is ensuring it meets airline size restrictions. While requirements vary between carriers, most domestic airlines in the United States allow carry-ons up to 22″ x 14″ x 9″. International carriers often have stricter limitations, particularly budget airlines in Europe and Asia.
Pro Tip: If you frequently fly on different airlines, opt for a carry-on that meets the most restrictive size requirements of carriers you commonly use. Some manufacturers offer “international carry-on” sizes specifically designed to meet global standards.
Weight Considerations
While domestic U.S. carriers rarely weigh carry-on bags, many international airlines enforce strict weight limits—typically between 15-22 pounds (7-10kg). An ultralight bag like the Travelpro Maxlite 5 (5.4 pounds) gives you more weight allowance for your actual belongings compared to heavier options like the Briggs & Riley Baseline (10 pounds).
Durability Factors
Consider these material choices based on your travel style:
Soft-Sided Materials
- Ballistic Nylon: Extremely abrasion-resistant and durable; premium choice for frequent travelers
- Cordura: Excellent tear resistance; often used in adventure-oriented luggage
- Polyester: Lightweight and affordable but less durable than nylon options
Hard-Sided Materials
- Polycarbonate: Lightweight with excellent impact resistance and flexibility
- ABS Plastic: More affordable but less durable than polycarbonate
- Aluminum: Extremely durable but heavy and expensive
Wheel Systems
Modern carry-ons typically feature one of two wheel configurations:
Spinner Wheels (4 wheels)
- 360° rotation allows multidirectional movement
- Easier to maneuver in tight spaces
- No weight on your arm or shoulder
- More prone to damage as wheels protrude
Roller Wheels (2 wheels)
- Larger, more durable wheels handle rough surfaces better
- More interior space as wheel housing is smaller
- More stable when standing upright
- Requires tilting and pulling, causing arm strain
Warranty Coverage
A quality warranty can significantly increase the value of your luggage investment. The best warranties cover not just manufacturing defects but also damage caused by airlines or normal wear and tear. Briggs & Riley and Travelpro (Platinum Elite line) offer standout warranty coverage that includes airline damage.
Warranty Tip: Always register your luggage immediately after purchase. Many manufacturers require registration within a specific timeframe (often 30-120 days) to activate full warranty benefits.
Organization Features
Consider these organizational elements based on your packing style:
- Compression Systems: Help maximize packing space and minimize wrinkles
- Garment Folders/Suitors: Essential for business travelers who need wrinkle-free formal attire
- External Pockets: Provide easy access to travel documents, electronics, and liquids
- Dividers and Compartments: Help separate clean clothes from dirty laundry or shoes from clothing
Frequently Asked Questions About Carry-On Luggage
Can carry-on luggage have wheels?
Yes, most carry-on luggage has wheels. In fact, wheeled suitcases are the most popular type of carry-on luggage. You can choose between two-wheel “roller” designs or four-wheel “spinner” designs. Spinner wheels offer 360-degree rotation for easier maneuverability in airports, while roller wheels are typically more durable and better suited for rough surfaces.
What’s the best lightweight carry-on luggage option?
The Travelpro Maxlite 5 21″ Spinner is one of the lightest carry-on options at just 5.4 pounds. For those who prefer a non-wheeled option, the Patagonia Black Hole MLC 45L weighs only 3.6 pounds. When shopping for lightweight luggage, look for materials like polycarbonate (for hard-sided) or polyester (for soft-sided), as these tend to weigh less than alternatives like aluminum or ballistic nylon.
Are hard or soft-sided carry-ons better?
Neither is universally “better”—it depends on your travel style and priorities:
Hard-sided luggage offers better protection for fragile items, is easier to clean, and often has a more modern aesthetic. However, it can show scratches more readily and lacks external pockets.
Soft-sided luggage typically offers more organizational features, external pockets for easy access items, and can compress slightly to fit in tight overhead bins. It’s generally more forgiving of rough handling but provides less protection for delicate contents.
What size carry-on is allowed on most airlines?
Most major U.S. airlines (including American, Delta, and United) allow carry-on bags up to 22″ x 14″ x 9″. Southwest is slightly more generous at 24″ x 16″ x 10″. International carriers often have stricter limits, particularly budget airlines. Always check your specific airline’s requirements before traveling, as exceeding size limits could result in gate-checking your bag and potential fees.
How much should I spend on quality carry-on luggage?
Quality carry-on luggage typically falls into these price ranges:
- Budget (0-0): Basic functionality with fewer premium features
- Mid-range (0-0): Good balance of quality and value for occasional travelers
- Premium (0-0): High-quality materials and features for frequent travelers
- Luxury (0+): Top-tier materials, craftsmanship, and warranties for road warriors
Frequent travelers should consider investing in higher-end options with better warranties, as the cost per use becomes quite reasonable over time. Occasional travelers can often find excellent value in the mid-range category.
What features are worth paying extra for in carry-on luggage?
The most valuable premium features to consider include:
- Comprehensive warranty coverage that includes airline damage
- High-quality wheel systems with replaceable parts
- Expansion capabilities for flexibility on different trips
- Premium materials like ballistic nylon or polycarbonate
- Thoughtful organization systems that maximize packing efficiency
Features like USB charging ports, GPS tracking, and digital scales are nice to have but typically less essential to the core functionality of your luggage.
Essential Packing Tips for Carry-On Travel
Maximizing your carry-on’s capacity requires strategic packing. Here are some expert tips to help you fit more while keeping everything organized:
Use Compression Techniques
- Roll softer clothing items like t-shirts and jeans to save space
- Use packing cubes to compress clothes and keep categories organized
- Consider vacuum compression bags for bulky items like sweaters
- Stuff socks and underwear inside shoes to utilize every inch
Pack Strategically
- Layer heavier items at the bottom near the wheels
- Pack shoes along the edges with soles facing outward
- Place toiletries in easily accessible locations for security screening
- Use the “rule of three” for clothing: limit yourself to three of each item type
Maximize Personal Item
- Choose a personal item with maximum allowed dimensions
- Use it for electronics, documents, and in-flight essentials
- Select a bag that can attach to your carry-on handle
- Consider a bag that can double as a day pack at your destination
“The true art of travel isn’t about how much you bring, but how little you need. A well-packed carry-on forces you to be intentional about every item.”
Remember that liquids, gels, and aerosols must comply with the TSA’s 3-1-1 rule: containers must be 3.4 ounces (100ml) or less, all containers must fit in one quart-sized clear bag, and only one bag is allowed per passenger. Consider solid alternatives like shampoo bars and stick deodorants to save space in your liquids bag.
Essential Carry-On Luggage Accessories
The right accessories can dramatically improve your carry-on travel experience. Here are some essentials worth considering:
Organization
- Packing Cubes: Eagle Creek Pack-It Isolate Compression Cubes compress clothes while keeping categories organized
- Toiletry Kit: Sea to Summit Travelling Light Hanging Toiletry Bag keeps essentials organized and TSA-compliant
- Cable Organizer: Keeps chargers and adapters tangle-free and easily accessible
Security & Identification
- TSA-Approved Lock: Secures your belongings while allowing security inspection
- Luggage Tags: Distinctive tags help identify your bag and provide contact information
- RFID-Blocking Wallet: Protects credit cards and passport from electronic theft
Comfort & Convenience
- Travel Pillow: Compact, packable neck support for long flights
- Portable Charger: Keeps devices powered during long travel days
- Collapsible Water Bottle: Stays empty through security, then fills for hydration
Important: Always check current TSA regulations before packing. Rules regarding electronics, liquids, and other items can change, and international destinations may have different security requirements.
Which Carry-On Luggage Is Right For You?
Choosing the perfect carry-on depends on your travel style, budget, and priorities. Here’s a quick guide to help you match your needs with our top recommendations:
- Need wrinkle-free clothing storage
- Value smooth maneuverability in airports
- Require professional appearance
- Appreciate organizational features
- Best Choice: Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential
- Budget Option: Travelpro Platinum Elite
Business Travelers
- Need versatile carrying options
- Value durability and weather resistance
- Often travel to remote locations
- Prioritize lightweight design
- Best Choice: Patagonia Black Hole MLC 45L
- Budget Option: The North Face Base Camp Voyager
Adventure Travelers
- Value aesthetic design
- Appreciate modern features
- Want luggage that stands out
- Enjoy customization options
- Best Choice: Away The Carry-On
- Budget Option: Delsey Helium Aero
Style-Conscious Travelers
- Need reliable performance
- Want maximum value
- Travel occasionally
- Prioritize lightweight design
- Best Choice: Travelpro Maxlite 5
- Alternative: Amazon Basics Hardside Spinner
Budget-Conscious Travelers
- Need exceptional durability
- Value comprehensive warranties
- Require efficient organization
- Appreciate premium components
- Best Choice: Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential
- Alternative: Travelpro Platinum Elite
Frequent Flyers
- Need maximum packing capacity
- Value expandable designs
- Require durable construction
- Appreciate external pockets
- Best Choice: Travelpro Platinum Elite
- Budget Option: Travelpro Maxlite 5
Family Travelers
Find Your Perfect Travel Companion
Ready to upgrade your travel experience with the perfect carry-on luggage?
Conclusion
Investing in quality carry-on luggage is one of the smartest decisions any traveler can make. The right bag not only streamlines your airport experience but can be a reliable companion for years or even decades of adventures. While our top picks represent the best options for different travel styles and budgets, the “perfect” carry-on ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences.
For most travelers, the Travelpro Platinum Elite offers an exceptional balance of quality, features, and value backed by an industry-leading warranty. Those seeking luxury should consider the Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential with its innovative compression system and unconditional lifetime guarantee. Budget-conscious travelers will appreciate the lightweight efficiency of the Travelpro Maxlite 5, while style-focused individuals will love Away’s sleek design and modern features.
Remember to consider your typical travel patterns, airline restrictions, and organizational preferences when making your selection. With the right carry-on by your side, you’ll be well-equipped for smoother, more enjoyable journeys for years to come.